Our Little Secret Cast & Character Guide

The cast of Netflix’s Our Little Secret features some major movie stars as well as some accomplished comedians and even a Tony-winning actress. Our Little Secret follows Avery (Lindsay Lohan) and Logan (Ian Harding) as they reunite ten years after Logan proposed and Avery refused. Unfortunately, that reunion happened at a holiday party hosted by their new significant others, who happened to be siblings. Avery and Logan decided to keep their past relationship secret, which helped make Our Little Secret one of the best romantic comedy movies on Netflix and one of the best Christmas movies on Netflix.

The cast of Our Little Secret features quite a few talented actors, like Lindsay Lohan, Ian Harding, and even Kristin Chenoweth. All of them bring comedic talents and more than enough chemistry to make Our Little Secret an entertaining film, and it even has the potential to be one of Lindsay Lohan’s best movies. The movie’s cast has also made quite a name for themselves in other genres, and there’s even a surprise reunion for Lohan and a former Mean Girls co-star, so learning about who stars in Our Little Secret is very interesting.

Lindsay Lohan As Avery

Date Of Birth: July 2, 1986

Actor: Lindsay Lohan was born in New York City, New York. Lohan’s breakthrough role was in The Parent Trap, a 1998 Disney Channel remake of the 1961 film. Lohan starred in The Parent Trap when she was only 12 years old, and she played two roles in the film. Since then, Lohan has starred in several classic films like the 2003 remake of Freaky Friday opposite Jamie Lee Curtis and Mean Girls opposite Rachel McAdams. More recently, Lohan has starred in a number of romantic comedies, including Falling for Christmas and Irish Wish.

Character: In Our Little Secret, Lindsay Lohan plays Avery, Logan’s ex-girlfriend and Cameron’s current girlfriend. Avery convinces Logan to keep their past relationship a secret so she can impress Cameron’s mother, Erica. Avery also has a love for snacks and a keen sense of humor.

Ian Harding As Logan

Date Of Birth: September 16, 1986

Actor: Ian Harding was born in Heidelberg, Baden-Württemberg, Germany. Harding’s breakthrough role was playing Ezra Fitz on Pretty Little Liars from 2010 to 2017. Since then, Harding has taken on various roles in shows like Chicago Med and Long Slow Exhale, as well as movies like Ford v Ferrari.

Character: In Our Little Secret, Ian Harding plays Logan, Avery’s ex-boyfriend and Cassie’s current boyfriend. Logan proposed to Avery and was turned down, and seeing her again years later sends him into a crisis. Even after a decade, however, he still has feelings for Avery.

Kristin Chenoweth As Erica

Date Of Birth: July 24, 1968

Actor: Kristin Chenoweth was born in Broken Arrow, Oklahoma. Chenoweth’s breakthrough role was not in a film or television series, but in the original Broadway run of the theatrical play Wicked, where she played Galinda. During her time on Broadway, Chenoweth became world-renowned for her incredible vocal range and singing abilities, and she was nominated for three Tony Awards and won one. On the screen, Chenoweth has mostly taken comedic roles.

Character: In Our Little Secret, Kristin Chenoweth plays Erica, Cameron and Cassie’s mother. Erica doesn’t give Avery the warmest welcome, and their relationship is a big reason Avery tries to hide her history with Logan.

Jon Rudnitsky As Cameron

Date Of Birth: November 22, 1989

Actor: Jon Rudnitsky was born in Harrington Park, New Jersey. Rudnitsky’s breakthrough role was in Saturday Night Live, where he worked as a cast member in season 41 in 2015 and 2016. Most recently, Rudnitsky had a role in Red One alongside stars like Chris Evans and Dwayne Johnson. Rudnitsky also has a fairly prolific voice acting career, as he’s played characters in Disney’s Wish and Nickelodeon’s Under the Boardwalk.

Character: In Our Little Secret, Jon Rudnitsky plays Cameron, Avery’s boyfriend, Erica’s son, and Cassie’s brother. Cameron is a “momma’s boy” in Our Little Secret.

Katie Baker As Cassie

Date Of Birth: Unknown

Actor: Katie Baker was born in America. Baker’s breakthrough role was in The Mosquito Coast, an Apple TV+ show where she played Claire. Baker has mostly taken on comedic roles in her acting career, drawing on her experience with the Trifecta Comedy troupe. Baker’s career has also been on a recent upward trend, as she joined the cast of The Sex Lives of College Girls in season 3.

Character: In Our Little Secret, Katie Baker plays Cassie, Logan’s girlfriend, Erica’s daughter, and Cameron’s sister. Cameron is much younger than Logan, and Avery makes sure to point that out.

Our Little Secret Supporting Cast & Characters

Jake Brennan as Callum: In Our Little Secret, Jake Brennan plays Callum Morgan. Callum is a younger brother of Cameron and Cassie, and he finds out how Avery and Logan know each other before others do. Brennan is known for the starring role in Richie Rich, and more recently movies like Dark Harvest.

Tim Meadows as Stan: Tim Meadows plays Stan in Our Little Secret. Stan is a family friend of the Morgans who is married to Margaret (Judy Reyes). Meadows is known for comedies like The Ladies Man and Mean Girls, where he starred with Lindsay Lohan.

Dan Bucatinsky as Leonard: Ban Bucatinsky plays Leonard in Our Little Secret. Leonard is the father of the Morgan family and married to Erica. Bucatinsky is known for the movie Air and the TV show Scandal.